Friday, October 23, 2020
Home Wellness Study Finding Patients of Female Surgeons Fare Better is Removed

Study Finding Patients of Female Surgeons Fare Better is Removed

An Elsevier journal has, for the moment, removed a paper which found that the patients of female surgeons fare better than those treated by men.

Although the journal didn’t provide an explanation for the move — unfortunately not unusual for Elsevier — a spokesman for the publisher told us that reader complaints about the methodology and statistics in the article prompted the action.

The paper, which appeared last month in Surgery — the official journal of the Society of University Surgeons, Central Surgical Association Central Surgical Association, and the American Association of Endocrine Surgeons — was written by a group at the University of South Florida, in Tampa, led by Tara M. Barry, a general surgery resident at the institution.

“Battle of the sexes: The effect of surgeon gender on postoperative in-hospital mortality,” isn’t available on the journal website. However, a conference abstract by the authors states:

Patients who underwent bariatric procedures, mastectomy and open cholecystectomy had lower rates of in-hospital mortality if the surgeon was female while male surgeons did not have a significant mortality advantage for any of the 25 procedures. Further studies examining national data may provide additional insight regarding the effect of surgeon gender on patient outcomes.

According to the notice, which Elsevier styles a “temporary removal”:

The publisher regrets that this article has been temporarily removed. A replacement will appear as soon as possible in which the reason for the removal of the article will be specified, or the article will be reinstated.

The paper — isn’t the first to find the gender effect in surgery — drew a bit of attention on social media. Most mentions simply called attention to the article. But one surgeon, Olga Muldoon, raised questions about the work:


We emailed Barry for comment but have not heard back.

Elsevier’s Andrew Davis told us:

It appears that, soon after the paper appeared online, the journal has received a complaint regarding the methodology and the statistics included in the paper. The Editors-in-Chief have decided to temporarily remove the Article-in-Press until the investigation is completed.

When the investigation will be finished, the AiP will be either reinstated on Science Direct or permanently withdrawn.

This article originally appeared on Retraction Watch.

Read More

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Festival bonanza: 11.58 lakh railway employees granted bonus equal to 78 days wages

The Indian Railways has said about 11.58 lakh of its non-gazetted employees have been granted bonus equivalent to 78 days' wages for FY 2019-20. The government hopes that bonuses to central government employees will help encourage spending during the festive season and add to demand in the economy (PTI photo)The Indian Railways on Thursday announced…

IPL 2020: Virat Kohli, Chahal and Rashid engage in hilarious banter over RCB captain’s ‘school days’ post

IPL 2020: RCB captain Virat Kohli came up with a hilarious social media post, saying a photo of himself, AB de Villiers, Devdutt Palikkal and Mohammed Siraj from the training session reminded him of 'school days'. Virat Kohli shared a hilarious photo, that reminded of his school days (Courtesy: virat.kohli Instagram)HIGHLIGHTSVirat Kohli shares funny photo…

A Lost Decade: Decoding the cost of Covid-19 pandemic

A decade after facing the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression in the 1930s, the world has again stumbled upon an unprecedented economic challenge due to a microscopic virus. The novel coronavirus pandemic, which forced governments around the world to lock down their respective economies, has spared no country on the globe.The International Monetary…

iPhone 12 series buying guide: Which is the best iPhone for you, which has best camera and other key details

Long ago choosing which iPhone to buy used to be easier. There was only one iPhone in the year. Then, the two iPhones became the norm as Apple launched an iPhone with a regular screen and one with a bigger screen. Then more iPhones were added in the mix. This time, and for the first…

Recent Comments